“Why we fight”
By Lee Davis • Jun 12th, 2009 • Category: Teaching and learningAs this is my last post before I leave the IB, I thought I would sign off by sharing with you some correspondence I have had with a person who has both inspired and encouraged me over the 7 years I have been with the organisation.
Barbara Stefanics has been a faculty member for the IB’s online curriculum centre since its inception way back in 1999 and has helped develop a community of learners in ITGS that is both self-sustaining and serves as a model for other curriculum areas within the programmes. She retired from that role last year in order to become the chief examiner for ITGS.
Over the years, we have exchanged ideas, experiences and stories related to technology in education and how it can transform the design of teaching and learning. Recently she shared the following with me. I have copied it verbatim because, to be honest, she tells it better than I do. It’s a great example of why we fight.
Dear Lee,
The Horizon Project which was amongst one of the first Flatclassroom Projects 2006-07.
http://horizonproject.wikispaces.com
My first collaborative global project with my ITGS class and David B was a member of this class.David B had diagnosed health problems that hindered both oral and written communication. He would stutter terribly - often struggling for minutes before he could say the one sentence that he needed to say. We all waited because we knew that that one sentence would have real value and substance. On any written work or test, additional time would make no difference. The longest response he could manage would be only a few words, up to a sentence.
One day in the staffroom (thank goodness for staffrooms), I bumped in to David B’s English teacher. We shared a common problem, and she gave me the first clue that there was a chance for communication. She told me that strangely, David B’s stuttering did not occur when he was involved in drama. That was quite a surprise.
As part of the horizon project there were two breakthroughs that gave me a hint of how to actually get a more reliable assessment for David B and by-pass the communication blocks. Both used technology.
1. All of the students in the horizon project were required to produce a video. David B produced this video at home on his own in his room. It was the evidence that I needed to show that David B could communicate just like any other student if he could use video or similar technology tools. Please go to
http://horizonproject.wikispaces.com/MMEG+Impact+on+Science+and+Enviroment+and+Health
to see the video … you have to scroll down until you see “Overview of MMEG’s Impact on Health” and David B’s picture on the screen.
2. The second indication I got was in the student meeting on Elluminate with Julie [Lindsay]. All of the students were expected to explain their outcomes of their research and the Horizon Project. I simply could not believe it! Right before my very eyes, David was completely articulate. Unfortunately, it was such a surprise that I did not record it in Elluminate.When I was in Cardiff at Grade Award 2007, I asked the subject area manager who I could speak to about this and he arranged for someone from the Special Ed’s office to meet with me. I showed her the video (1 above) and this actually started the process going that David B got the opportunity to record his IB examinations in ITGS and English with a microphone.
The result was that instead of a grade 0-1 for ITGS, he got a 5. He also passed his IB! It is truly the most amazing success story of my entire teaching career and all due to the support from IBCA for such a special case.
I thought you would enjoy this and the proof that technology opens doors for special students.
If you have similar stories to tell, please share them. It matters.
Thanks for listening and, as an old mucker of mine used to say, “Have fun!”
Lee


Dear Lee,
We didn’t communicate as much as would have been best - too busy I am sure, but the short time I spent with you helped me to grow a vital skill for my work. It was good to meet someone with whom one could share views and values and beliefs. In such a caring way. It will be sad to know you are not there in the Cardiff office but I hope we will meet again!
Good Luck,
Robert
Amazing outcomes but, unfortunately, they depend on technology- which is not always affordable.
Lee, thank you for publishing Barbara’s letter as it is truly a story that needs to be told and shared around the world. After reading this, and after seeing the evidence, there can be no doubt that technology does provide the scaffolding and support for learning that is needed to fully offer students alternative assessment choices to be able to reach their personal best. There is no ‘one size fits all’ in the world and there is a whole world of choices to explore that will provide the means to more effectively communicate, collaborate and create - essential 21st century skills!
Can I add, and this is not an advertisement but me wanting to share some wonderful experiences, the Flat Classroom Conference student reflection at http://flatclassroomconference.ning.com/video/compilation-of-student shows young people and their thoughts on being brought together in the Middle East to collaborate and plan towards a better future.
Also, our recent Digiteen Project, school from PA, USA, and their final social action where they put together a video on anti- bullying and presented it to the whole school….inspiring and encouraging events that put students at the center of learning and provide them with choices for expression!
http://digiteen09-2.flatclassroomproject.org/Action_Mt_Carmel
I am in complete awe of the work Barbara has done and firmly agree with you….this is why we fight!
Lee, you will be very much missed at the IB….I do hope we stay in touch as you start your next adventure.
Good luck!
Julie
Lee,
I’m sorry not to have shared with you your last year in the IB, but I’m grateful for all your hard work and wish you much success and joy in your new adventure. Don’t forget to blog!
Tom Hemingway
Several thoughts:
So sad to know you are leaving, Lee. You have added mightily to the work of IB.
I am reminded of a friend of my father and me who taught at Harvard Univ and stammered horribly in conversation but not when he sang. I know other cases, of that as well.
My wife is taking a class in Spanish from a school in Mexico, Encuentros, using Elluminate interface. Wow. Very slick.
Next, I just tutored my nephew in preparation for his Physics exam via Skype. He lives thousands of miles away. It was so easy to be able to draw diagrams to use to talk and show them to him.
There is no doubt in my mind that the Technolgy is very powerful and useful. It can and does fulfill many roles. I do worry about overdependence on it, however. The crash of the Air France flight seems to fall into that category, though more needs be known there.
Yes we should fight on to build and enhance the appropriate and creative use of technolgy. Yes we also need be alert to the abuses of this tool.
Adieu, Lee.